Shannon G.
10/24/2025
Needed a smash cake and cupcakes for a first person. They were a big hit! Everyone enjoyed them! Highly recommend. Communication was great!
Amy's Custom Cakery
$$
Closed
(23)
Advertisement
Photos
83 W Canal St
Dover, PA 17315
Amy's Custom Cakery is a small cake shop located in Dover, PA, specializing in creating custom cakes and cupcakes for various occasions.
With a focus on quality and creativity, Amy's Custom Cakery offers a wide range of custom cake designs, including wedding cakes and cookies, making it a popular choice for couples in York, PA, looking for the best wedding cakes in the area.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.523 reviewsHeather C.
12/29/2025
I walked in to check out what they had available since I had never bought anything there. I was greeted promptly. The cupcakes I bought did NOT disappoint! They were fresh and delicious. They're...
Debbie B.
8/28/2024
Ordered a birthday number cupcake cake for my daughter's birthday and Amy did not disappoint! The cupcake cake was beautiful and tasted great. I emailed the business through their site and got a...
Evelyn G.
5/27/2025
I ordered custom cupcakes for a baby shower, and i was truly blown away when i picked them up!! Everyone was so nice on the phone and in person, the cupcakes were not only decorated perfectly and...
Deb D.
1/25/2025
Left a recent review in another post! Best custom cake ever! Happy Birthday my dear daughter in Heaven. Spread your wings with the butterflies!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement