History
C. Wayne Matthews, Sr. founded Matthews Insurance in 2003 and merged with First Pioneer Insurance in 2017.
Specialties
We are excited to announce that Matthews Insurance merged with First Pioneer Insurance Agency on May 1, 2017. The new agency represents a tremendous opportunity for all of our customers as it will enable us to provide a broader set of services to you. Clayton Evans (First Pioneer Insurance former Vice President) and Wayne Matthews (Matthews Insurance former President) will serve as Co-Owners and Agency Principals. All of our current insurance companies, including Erie Insurance, will be part of the new agency and you will not see any disruption in service. Both agencies are extremely proud of the quality of their agents, the quality of their insurance products, and the quality of their service. You can expect the same focus, the same great customer service, and the same team that you have come to know. We hope you will join us in celebrating this major milestone as it provides an exciting opportunity for you, our clients, and our agency. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us. Thank you for the confidence you have placed in Matthews Insurance. We look forward to our continued partnership and working with you in the years to come.