Pretty to Think So

Closed
yelp logo

(41)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

6417 Montgomery St
Rhinebeck, NY 12572
+1 (845) 516-4556
https://www.prettytothink.so
Utilizing fresh, locally-sourced or grown ingredients, {pretty to think so} is Rhinebeck’s newest destination for farm-to-table fine dining and craft cocktails. Our menu offers a seasonal range of options to satisfy every palate, and features vegan, gluten-free, and dairy-free choices, along with a cocktail list which provides low-ABV and zero-proof alternatives in addition to traditional selections. We also offer the freshest oyster and caviar service in the Hudson Valley. Featured on the cover of Hudson Valley Magazine's Best New Restaurants of 2023 issue - the design-forward bar and restaurant takes its name from the last line of Hemingway’s “The Sun Also Rises” and is located in the town’s historic library, The Starr Institute, providing an unforgettable hospitality experience.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.041 reviews
Photo of Robert G.
Robert G.
10/27/2025

We had an enjoyable evening. Food was good. We all enjoyed our meal. Vegan stuffed squash ratatouille, with herbs, rice, etc. I'm grateful for a real meal, but I think it needed to be on a base...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of T C.
T C.
9/26/2025

Three stars feels generous, but here we are. This place is charging *fine dining* prices while serving in more of a bistro/tavola calda setting. Let's just say the math doesn't quite add up....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Don V.
Don V.
12/23/2025

When dining becomes an experience, my wife and I take note. We had a reservation for a table but opted to sit at the bar as we are "bar people". The bone marrow appetizer was amazing and the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Catherine T.
Catherine T.
10/8/2025

Service and ambiance were lovely, but the food was meh. Trying too hard to be something and they would do better to keep things simple and make them flavorful and wonderful.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Craig A.
Craig A.
11/27/2024

Gosh, what a pleasure to dine here. I chose it after reviewing a number of comments and I (and my guest) were extremely pleased with the meal. Fairly priced and excellent service. Indoor and...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Pizza restaurants

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

148
•
$$
"Ordered for pickup and my food was brought out promptly once I said I was there. I left special instructions on my order and they were adhered to. The restaurant itself looked well kept and..."
photo of Jessica H.
Outback Steakhouse
Eating places, Pizza restaurants, Steak restaurant

Outback Steakhouse

190
•
$$
"unbeatable. I thought I liked this place, until Chris was our server and I realized... I LOVE it. He was bringing us things before we even knew we needed them. An amazing server. Youd be lucky to..."
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Bars and lounges

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

126
•
$$
"I came to Olive Garden and ordered the Chicken Alfredo with soup. The soup was warm, not hot, but the main dish was fine. Service started out pretty good, but toward the end, things lost their..."
photo of Kenny D.
United States›New York›Rhinebeck›Pretty to Think So

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement