Pappalardo's Pizza Cove

77 reviews

+1 (516) 731-9299

Website

Photos

Where's the meat???? Taste like paste and not pasta

This & several other 2 liter diet cokes in their fridge behind the counter were nearly 4 months past the best by date

1079 Hicksville Rd

Seaford, NY 11783

+1 (516) 731-9299

http://pappalardopizzacove.food94.com

Pappalardo's Pizza Cove has been rated by Long Island's Newsday newspaper for having the best pizza on Long Island. Maybe it's because the staff makes its dough fresh every day. Pappalardo's offers a wide selection of delectable pizza, pasta and Italian dishes.

Also at this address

Plainedge Youth Baseball League

Find related places

Places To Eat

Pizza

Reviews

3.577 reviews

Michael L.

6/23/2024

This local legend is the only pizza cove in New York!! PAPPALARDO's has great weekly & family specials that are among some of the best pizza deals around! The service is always great providing...

Read more on Yelp

Melanie D.

6/11/2023

You can feel the family energy in here, sweet young folks working at the front have a decent variety of pizza. The slices are on the heavier side when it comes to the dough so if that's your pizza...

Read more on Yelp

Mindy M.

3/18/2023

Found Pappalardo's Pizza Cove in Massapequa, a nook in the cranny in the Island Recreational Pools shopping center across the ;parking lot from Time Flies Ceramics. I went in and ordered a Pie 1.2...

Read more on Yelp

Drew R.

9/8/2021

This is a new review, because yelp would not let me update my old one. I previously had an experience at the restaurant that did not go so well, and the manager reached out to me and made things...

Read more on Yelp

mattie b.

10/27/2023

Good place to grab a bite of pizza. The pinwheels are my favorite. Stratis one of the employees there is top tier!

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?