Buttercooky Bakery

826 reviews

+1 (516) 354-3831

Website

Photos

Custom cake for surprise birthday of avid fishing enthusiast. Mermaid is pulling the fishing line!

217 Jericho Tpke

Floral Park, NY 11001

+1 (516) 354-3831

https://www.buttercookybakery.com

For over 50 years Buttercooky Bakery has served Long Island residents fresh-baked cookies, pastries and cakes. Our flagship store has become a Floral Park fixture and our Manhasset store has been building a following for a decade and counting...

Also at this address

Matte Electric Inc

Find related places

Bakery

Places To Eat

Reviews

3.5826 reviews

Revathi N.

11/7/2024

Thank you for our delicious cake that we had at our reception at Floral Terrace on June 15th. Everyone was raving about the flavor, design, and it was everything that I had ever wished for in a...

Read more on Yelp

Christy Y.

11/5/2024

I rarely come this neighborhood because I'm from Brooklyn. It's a little too far, but when I do come it's to run errands. I've walked by Buttercooky Bakery a handful of times but never went in...

Read more on Yelp

Danielle A.

10/10/2024

Never again. We bought a cake here yesterday. I served it to guests in my home and it was STALE! So embarrassing. I brought it back to the store and was told that because there is too much of the...

Read more on Yelp

Natalie L.

8/26/2024

Good service employees are so nice and helpful. Great pastries, cakes, and cookies. There're prices are reasonable. Wide variety of different sizes and types of cakes. For my coworker's birthday...

Read more on Yelp

Hasna D.

12/5/2024

I have been going to this bakery for over 10 years. Staff is great, and let me tell you the tres leches cake is my weakness!!! They also have mini cakes which is nice!! Loveeee this bakery!!

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?