The only church in Bayport, the Bayport United Methodist Church is located at the intersection of Snedecor Avenue and Middle Road. Several organizations, including the Boy and Girl Scouts, Bayport Civic Association and Alcoholics Anonymous, hold meetings here. Bayport United Methodist Church hosts youth nights on Wednesdays and offers numerous other services and programs for both children and adults.
Worship services are held every Sunday at 9:45am; Sunday school also takes place at 9:45am.