Bagels Your Way Cafe

145 reviews

+1 (631) 758-6467

Website

Photos

This is the initial view of the sandwich dry and flaky.

This is my one piece of lettuce and on top of that its browning already.

2799 Route 112

Medford, NY 11763

+1 (631) 758-6467

http://bagelsyourway.com

Bagels Your Way Cafe is more than a typical bagel shop. With its high-end ingredients and three locations, Bagels Your Way has consistently been voted Long Island's best bagel shop. The menu includes its great bagels as well as omelets, deli sandwiches, salads and specialty sandwiches that are perfect for a hearty lunch. Bagels Your Way offers catering service for a variety of events.

Also at this address

Walker Garage Door Repair Service

Find related places

Bakery

Bagels

Food

Places To Eat

Dessert

Coffee

Reviews

2.5145 reviews

Tony O.

4/8/2024

I'll keep this one short. My sandwich was fine, but the water quality used for the iced tea had a nasty aftertaste and had to be ditched.

Read more on Yelp

Samantha C.

1/7/2024

One of the more decent bagel spots in the area. This might be an unpopular opinion, but Suffolk County has a tough time when it comes to good bagels. The bagels here are comparable to Nassau and...

Read more on Yelp

Justin E.

8/3/2024

I got two chicken cutlet sandwiches. It cost almost $30 and it literally came with nothing but chicken cutlet and bread. If I wanted anything more, it would've been $1 extra per add on, per...

Read more on Yelp

John A.

9/20/2024

Egg sandwiches are fine but $8 for a bacon and egg on a roll is ridiculous. They must get there from the golden goose. Last time for me as there are so many other options within 2 miles. Greedy...

Read more on Yelp

Bruno L.

4/14/2024

The Service was nice, but I got two chicken cutlets two small chips and 2 small drinks and the total was almost 40$ I didn't mind I paid and left. WHYY did my sandwich have one piece of lettuce...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?