Nicholas Creamery

29 reviews

+1 (848) 456-4035

Website

Photos

Flight of 6 flavors - $8.50 as of 6/10/2023

If you have a group and want to try every flavor, I recommend getting the flights.

1201 Sycamore Ave

Tinton Falls, NJ 07724

+1 (848) 456-4035

https://www.nicholascreamery.com

Nicholas Creamery is a charming ice cream shop in Tinton Falls, NJ, offering a variety of handcrafted ice cream flavors made with high-quality ingredients.

With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, Nicholas Creamery provides a delightful experience for customers looking to enjoy a sweet treat in a welcoming setting.

Generated from their business information

Also at this address

Jimmy Pecci's Taste of Italy

20 reviews

Village Drugs

Golden City

2 reviews

Align Amar Yoga

3 reviews

Find related places

Food

Places To Eat

Ice Cream

Reviews

4.529 reviews

Marissa G.

5/17/2024

For next time: DO NOT get the cookie dough, you will want to, get something more adventurous Lavender-great, but try something else Ricotta-very good

Read more on Yelp

Mark V.

12/31/2023

This has got to be the freshest, most delicious, and best ice cream in Monmouth county! I can't believe I just found out about this place!! Go here! I don't know what else to tell you. This has...

Read more on Yelp

Ohai B.

10/4/2024

Pricy but you get what you pay for! The ice cream is consistently fantastic. They have their OG flavors but then add in new small batch flavors on rotation. Sounds weird, but in August when they...

Read more on Yelp

Neil M.

11/13/2023

I discovered Nicholas Creamery many years ago in Atlantic Highlands and was blown away by their exceptional quality and unique flavors (lemon blueberry remains my favorite). Once they opened up at...

Read more on Yelp

Jonathan R.

9/13/2023

Solid Ice Cream shop with homemade ice cream flavors. Service is great Prices are high but on par for small batch ice cream. Bourbon is my favorite flavor.

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?