This multi-ethnic church dates back to 1858 and is affiliated with the worldwide United Methodist Church (UMC). The pastor, Rev. Anna Thomas, takes pride in her church's community involvement. The Livingston UMC works with the local Senior Center, and it is part of the interfaith CHOW program (Community Hunger Outreach Warehouse). The United Methodist Church also does its own work with the Community Food Bank and a Methodist soup kitchen in Orange. Several past and current town officials are members of this church.