History
We had our first restaurant at 207 Petronia St, where Santiago's is now from 2001-2003 called Petronia's Polish Restaurant. We then moved to Winter Park and opened Polonia Polish Restaurant at 3586 Aloma Ave from 2003-2005. In 2007 we opened Polonia again in Longwood, Florida and remained there until 2017. In 2018 we moved back to Key West. In February of 2020 we opened the Red Shoe Grill inside the Bourbon St complex next door. In July of 2020 we opened Red Shoe Island Bistro here at 411 Petronia. We are Marek Andruniow from Poland and Rob Plummer from Cleveland.
Specialties
This restaurant specializes in fresh Key West fish and shrimp delivered daily from the fishery here. In addition to the local seafood, this restaurant bakes its own Key Lime Pie the old-fashioned way. Please make a reservation here on Yelp. Seating is very limited. Beer and Wine Available. Small romantic restaurant not a great fit for infants and toddlers.