Sleepy Hollow Presbyterian Church, off of Van Winkle Drive, is a neighborhood church serving the Sleepy Hollow community. The church was organized in 1908 and has grown and evolved since then. In the late 1990s, the church built a manse to house the pastor and offer more room for the church.
The church offers age-specific youth programs, as well as adult programs like choir, book clubs, socials and an annual retreat. One of the church's service programs, the Mexico Mission, has parishioners traveling to Mexico to build houses.